In November of 2022,I decided I needed to organize my pocket EDC (everyday carry) gear. As part of that reorganization, I picked up aKeySmart Air key organizer as a way to both keep my keys sorted and also attach anAirTag to them.

Also: 10 tiny tools I carry with me everywhere - how they work

So, here we are, almost three years on, and I'm still using the KeySmart Air, and while it's looking a little battered, it's still going strong.

KeySmart AirTag Keychain Key Holder

$29.99 at Amazon

The KeySmart Air comes in three versions --faux leather , leather , and apolymer variant called Flex (I'm sure only the leather and faux leather were available when I bought mine -- and I went for the faux SmartShield leather version because KeySmart said it had a "rugged leather feel" yet lasted "10x longer than traditional leather." That sounded good to me.

Also: My new favorite keychain holder can carry up to 14 keys (and is trackable by phone)

The idea behind the KeySmart Air is simple -- it's a loop of material where the keys fit onto a screw fastener, and the AirTag fits into a molded loop. Fitting your keys into the holder is quite easy: All you need is a flat-headed screwdriver (or a thin coin).

Simple, but it's super effective.

What I like about the KeySmart line is that they make a ton of cool accessory tools that fit into the Air or their other key organizers, such as amini knife (not TSA friendly, so be aware of that), atiny 5-in-1 multitool , amagnetic breakaway connector , and a range of othersmall but useful multitools . I have quite a few of these accessories; they're all good quality and worth the money.

So, how has the KeySmart Air held up to almost three years of use? 

Very well. Sure, it looks rougher than when I got it out of the box, but it's still perfectly functional and serviceable. The material is still perfectly intact, and the screw fastener that holds the keys is like new. And for$30, I can't complain. 

Also: I never leave home without this viral USB-C key ring accessory

One modification that I did to my KeySmart Air was to replace the supplied metal split ring with aKeyUnity titanium D-ring shackle because that was both more convenient and a more robust choice for my setup. It was an easy upgrade to personalize an already valuable tool for my lifestyle. 

Why I recommend this product

Things that are part of my EDC get quite a hard life, and when I picked up theKeySmart Air I was curious to see how well it would hold up. And now several years on, I'm happy to report that it's been fantastic. It's securely held my keys, tools, and AirTag, and has lasted through daily use without a hitch.

It's one of the nicest AirTag holders I've used, far nicer and more compact than the pendant-style holders. I'm not a fan of the silicone AirTag holders because I've had some where the tag has fallen out. There's no chance of that with the KeySmart Air.

The faux leather has held up surprisingly well, but I am curious how well the genuine leather and polymer would hold up. I might get some to test!

Looking for the next best product? Get expert reviews and editor favorites with Recommends.

Featured reviews

Why I recommend this$2,000 mirrorless camera to both beginners and professionals

Finally, an ultraportable Windows laptop I'd use at the office (even though it's for gamers)

Why I recommend this budget phone with a paper-like screen over other 'minimalist' devices

I replaced my Samsung OLED TV with this Sony Mini LED model for a week - and didn't regret it

• Why I recommend this$2,000 mirrorless camera to both beginners and professionals
• Finally, an ultraportable Windows laptop I'd use at the office (even though it's for gamers)
• Why I recommend this budget phone with a paper-like screen over other 'minimalist' devices
• I replaced my Samsung OLED TV with this Sony Mini LED model for a week - and didn't regret it